Most disappointing carving orders are not fraud. They are a buyer and a supplier understanding different things by the same words. "Stone" can mean a solid block of natural material, or crushed stone bound in resin. "Black obsidian" can mean obsidian, or glass made to look like it.

Here is how to tell the difference, and what to ask so you do not have to guess.

The three things being confused

Natural carved stone. A single piece of solid mineral, shaped by cutting and grinding. What most buyers think they are ordering.

Reconstituted stone. Stone dust or chips mixed with resin and moulded or pressed into a shape. It contains real stone, which is why the description can be technically true, but it is not a carved block. Also sold as "recon stone" or "bonded stone".

Resin or polymer. No stone at all, coloured and weighted to imitate one.

All three can look convincing in a photograph. The differences appear in the hand, in the weight, and later on the shelf.

Checks you can do without equipment

Weight. This is the most reliable quick test. Mineral is dense: quartz sits around 2.6–2.7 g/cm³ and obsidian around 2.4. Common resins are roughly 1.1–1.2. For the same size, a genuine stone piece should feel distinctly heavier — often more than twice as heavy as resin.

> Weigh it against its own dimensions rather than by feel. If you know a piece is 12 × 7 × 9 cm and it weighs far less than a comparable stone piece, be suspicious. Volume × density gives you a rough expected weight.

Temperature. Stone feels cold when you first hold it and takes a while to warm to your hand. Resin feels close to room temperature immediately, and warms quickly.

Sound. Tap the piece lightly with a fingernail or a coin. Stone gives a short, hard click. Resin gives a duller, flatter sound.

Inclusions. Natural stone contains irregularities: internal fractures, colour zoning, mineral specks, cloudy patches. Resin imitations tend to be either uniformly coloured or patterned in a way that repeats. A pattern that repeats across two pieces is a strong sign of moulding.

Mould lines and seams. Look along the jawline, under the brow ridge and around the base. Moulded pieces can carry a faint seam or a slight flat where the mould met. A carved piece has tool marks and hand-finished transitions instead.

Surface wear. Scratch a hidden area — the underside of the base — with a steel pin. Resin and reconstituted stone mark easily and may shave. Quartz and agate around Mohs 7 will resist; a pin should not cut them.

Reconstituted stone specifically

This is the hardest to catch, because it is partly genuine. Clues:

  • Uniform fine speckle across the whole piece, with no larger natural features
  • Lower weight than solid stone of the same volume, but heavier than pure resin — often the giveaway when the piece feels almost right
  • Warm to the touch, unlike solid mineral
  • Edges that are slightly rounded or soft in a way that suggests pressing rather than carving
  • A smell of resin when the base is rubbed or warmed

Dyed and treated material

Separate issue, and not automatically bad — but it must be disclosed.

  • Dyed howlite sold as turquoise is one of the oldest substitutions in the trade. Natural howlite is white with grey veining; dyed howlite is bright blue and the colour sits in the veins.
  • Dyed agate is common, particularly bright pinks and blues. Dye concentrates in the banding and cracks, so look for colour pooled in fissures while the surrounding stone stays paler.
  • Heat-treated quartz. Amethyst heated to around 400–500 °C turns yellow and is sold as citrine. This is a normal, accepted treatment — the problem is only when it is described as natural citrine.
  • Irradiated quartz. Used to darken or colour some material.

None of these make a piece worthless. They make it a different product at a different price, and your customer is entitled to know which one they are buying.

What to ask a supplier in writing

Put these in an email rather than a chat, and keep the answer:

  1. Is this carved from a single solid block? If not, what is it?
  2. Is the colour natural, or dyed, heated or irradiated?
  3. If it is a trade name, what mineral is it actually?
  4. Can you send photographs of the specific pieces — including the base and any flaws?
  5. What is the finished weight and L × W × H of the actual piece?
  6. Will the invoice state the material and treatment?

A supplier who answers all six plainly is telling you more than any photograph will.

Certification, for high-value pieces

For an expensive piece, an independent gem laboratory can confirm the material and detect resin-filled or treated stone. It costs money and takes time, so it is normally reserved for large or high-value commissions rather than routine stock. Ask for it when the sum involved justifies it.

We sell material we have carved in our own workshop, and every product page states the material and treatment status. If something has not been verified, we say so rather than letting you assume. See how we label material or ask about a specific piece.