Here is the calculation almost everyone does when they price a carved stone piece for the first time.

The landed cost is $60. Retail is meant to be keystone — double it — so the price is $120, and the margin is 50%.

That number is wrong, and it is wrong by a wide enough margin to matter. Run the same piece through the costs that actually come out of a cross-border retail sale and the contribution lands near $14, or about 12% of the retail price.

The piece still sells. The store still works. But the owner believes they are running a 50% business and is running a 12% one, which is the difference between expanding next year and quietly running out of cash.

This article is about closing that gap before you commit to a price.

Stone is priced by weight, not by design

Most product categories price by brand, by design or by what the market will bear. Dense stone carvings price by weight, and the reason is physical: the block is bought by weight, the carving time scales with volume, and freight — the cost that most often decides whether a cross-border sale is profitable — is billed on weight.

This is measurable, not theoretical. Across a real 20-piece manufacturer range spanning 1.32 lb to 9.08 lb and $109 to $559, published retail price and weight correlate at r² = 0.95. Weight alone explains almost all of the price variation. Design, colour and rarity move the number; weight sets it.

If you are pricing a stone range, that figure tells you the single most useful thing you can know: weight is the variable to build your price ladder around.

The second number: what the range charges per kilogram

Price per kilogram is the number worth calculating, because it is the one that lets you compare a small piece against a large one.

In the same 20-piece range it is far flatter than the folklore suggests:

PieceWeightRetailRetail per kg
LightestTiger eye1.32 lb (0.60 kg)$119$198
Mid-rangeObsidian2.65 lb (1.20 kg)$169$141
HeaviestRose quartz9.08 lb (4.12 kg)$559$136

Retail per kilogram runs from $113 to $198 — a spread of about 1.75x. The lightest piece carries 1.46 times the per-kilogram rate of the heaviest, so the effect is real, but it is nothing like the steady downward ladder the phrase "cheaper per kilogram in bulk" implies. Step through the range in weight order and the rate falls eleven times and rises eight. The lighter half of the range averages $158 per kilogram; the heavier half averages $155. That is a two per cent difference.

What does move the rate is the stone, not the size. The same material at four times the weight carries almost the same rate — rose quartz at 1.02 kg and at 4.12 kg both come in at $136 per kilogram. Two different materials a few grams apart in weight can differ by more than a third: red obsidian and labradorite are within 1.5 per cent of each other by weight and 35 per cent apart by rate.

Two things follow.

For you as a buyer: a large piece is not automatically better value per kilogram, and a small piece is not automatically a bad deal. Check the rate on the specific piece rather than assuming a direction.

For you as a seller, and this is the part that costs money: the retail rate being roughly flat does not mean your cost per kilogram is also flat. Three things push your cost per kilogram down as pieces get bigger, and none of them appear in a price list:

  1. Manufacturing cost scales sub-linearly. A block four times heavier does not take four times as long to cut, grind and polish. Some of the work is setup and handling, paid once per piece regardless of size.
  2. Fixed per-piece costs amortise over more kilograms. Inspection, individual packing, export cartoning, documentation and handling are close to constant per piece. On a 0.6 kg piece they are a large share of the price; on a 4 kg piece they are almost nothing per kilogram.
  3. Freight has the same shape. Part of a parcel's cost is per box rather than per kilogram, so the cost of moving a kilogram falls as the piece gets heavier.

The practical consequence: applying one multiplier to landed cost underprices your large pieces and overprices your small ones. Your cost per kilogram fell as the piece grew; the retail rate did not. The big piece absorbs the most capital, carries the most freight and the most breakage risk, and — under a flat markup — earns the thinnest percentage.

There is a market reason too, and it points the same way. Far fewer customers will spend $500 than $120, so the top of a range is easier to overprice than to underprice, and a flat multiplier ignores that entirely.

If you take one thing from this article, take that.

The costs that have to be in the number

A retail price has to cover more than the goods. For a cross-border stone sale, this is the full list:

CostRoughlyNotes
Goods, freight and duty (landed)variesThe number on your supplier's invoice is not this one
Inbound payment fees~1–3%Bank or platform charges on paying your supplier
Outbound shipping to the customeroften the largest variable costWeight-billed, and stone is heavy
Outbound packaging$2–5Individual box, void fill, tape, label
Payment processing~3% + fixedCard and wallet fees
Platform or marketplace fee0–7%Marketplace listing fee, or a storefront platform's transaction fee
Damage and breakage reserve~2–5%See below — this one is not optional
Returns and refunds~2–5%Some of it is unrecoverable on stone
Photography, listing and admin labourper SKUReal time, even if unpaid
Advertising, if used0–15%Marketplace ad programmes can be mandatory above a sales threshold

Two of those lines deserve their own section, because they are the ones most often left out entirely.

Cost one: outbound shipping on dense stone

Freight is usually recorded as an inbound cost and then forgotten on the way out — but for a retail sale, the outbound leg is often the bigger of the two, and it is billed on the same weight that makes the product valuable.

A 1.3 lb carving ships affordably. A 9 lb carving does not, especially with tracking, insurance and a signature — which you want on a piece worth several hundred dollars, because an undelivered $559 order is a total loss, not a partial one.

This is why the heaviest pieces are the ones where a flat markup fails worst. They carry the most shipping, the most duty and the most capital, and the flat multiplier gives them the least percentage margin.

Cost two: the breakage reserve

Stone is brittle. A carved piece with thin sections — a jawline, a brow, an eye socket — can arrive intact and crack later, and a customer who receives a broken carving wants a replacement, not a discussion.

If you sell 100 pieces and three arrive damaged, you have lost three units of landed plus outbound shipping cost, plus the cost of the replacement's shipping. That is a real percentage of revenue whether or not you have booked it anywhere.

Treat it as a cost of sale from the first order, not as bad luck when it happens. Reserving 2–5% is not pessimism; it is the price of doing business in a fragile category, and it lets you promise replacements generously, which is what actually protects the reviews.

Free shipping is a pricing decision, not a marketing one

Offering free shipping on a heavy stone piece is the same as cutting your price by the shipping cost. On a 9 lb cross-border parcel that can be $40 or more.

If you want to advertise free shipping — and for retail it converts well — then it has to be built into the price first, not deducted afterwards. Work out the shipping cost for the heaviest item in each band, add it to the price, and then advertise it as included.

The version that fails is deciding on free shipping after setting prices that already assumed the customer paid for it.

The pieces that do not sell

Every retail range has slow movers. If you buy across ten designs and three sit for a year, those three have to be paid for by the seven that move.

This is where the arithmetic gets uncomfortable, because slow stock does not just fail to earn — it costs. The money in it could have been in a second order of something that works, and the stock itself occupies shelf space and eventually gets discounted, which puts the loss on the record in a way the original margin calculation never predicted.

Two defences that work better than optimism:

  • Order breadth across price bands rather than across designs. One small piece, one mid piece and one large piece will teach you more about your customers than five variations of the same size. See how to choose crystal skulls for your store.
  • Re-price slow stock early. A piece that has not moved in four months is not going to move at month ten. Cut it while it is still current and put the money back into what is selling.

Work backwards from the margin you need, not forwards from cost

This is the method that replaces the flat markup.

Start from the net contribution you need — after fees, shipping, packaging and reserve — and solve for the retail price. The formula, where R is retail:

`` R = (landed + outbound shipping + packaging) / (1 − fee% − target net%) ``

Using the same illustrative inputs throughout (landed $60, shipping $28, packaging $3, and 12.5% combined in payment and platform fees):

Target net contributionRetail neededMultiple of landed cost
20%$1352.25x
30%$1582.64x
40%$1923.19x
50%$2434.05x

Read the second row against the opening example. Keystone — the "2x" multiplier — does not appear anywhere in that table, because on a cross-border sale of a dense object, 2x does not produce a retail business. The low end of the table starts above it.

> The numbers above are illustrative, and deliberately so. Your landed cost, your shipping quote and your platform fees will differ. The shipping figure is the one to verify first — get a real quote on your heaviest piece before you price anything, because it moves the table more than any other input.

The lever that changes everything: shipping cost

Notice how much of that table is driven by the shipping line rather than the goods.

Reducing outbound shipping from $28 to $12 — through domestic stock, a consolidated inbound shipment, or regional warehousing — moves the whole table down:

Target net contributionRetail if shipping is $28Retail if shipping is $12
20%$135$111
30%$158$130
40%$192$158

Cutting the shipping line by $16 cuts the required retail price by roughly $24–34. That is why the single most valuable thing you can do for your margins is not negotiated on the product price at all — it is logistics. See sea versus air freight for how that choice plays out on heavy stone, and packaging because packaging that prevents one breakage pays for a lot of void fill.

Cost-plus gives you a floor, not a price

Everything above produces a minimum. It answers "below this number I lose money." It does not answer "what will this sell for."

Those are different questions, and the market answers the second one. If comparable pieces sell for less than your floor, the problem is your cost structure — not your pricing — and the fix is upstream: a different material, a smaller size, a lighter form, or a supplier conversation. Discounting below your floor to match the market means paying for the privilege of making a sale.

If your floor sits well below the market, hold the price and keep the difference. There is no prize for being the cheapest carved stone in a category where the material itself signals quality.

Your retail price is yours to set

We are not going to tell you what to charge. A manufacturer that sets its resellers' prices is really setting its own margin ceiling, and it is not a favour to anyone — the reseller ends up defending a number they did not choose. Set your price.

There is one fact worth knowing before you do, because it is arithmetic rather than advice: if the maker sells the same piece direct, that price is visible to your customers. That cuts both ways. It gives you a ceiling on anything identical, and it means a customer comparing the two has to be given a reason to buy from you — service, a piece in hand rather than a wait, a local return path, a presentation the maker does not offer.

If your numbers only work at a price above the maker's direct price, the margin has to come from somewhere other than the same object. That is what exclusivity buys: a custom size, a design your customers cannot buy elsewhere, your own packaging, a material the maker does not stock. A real difference in the product does not have to be defended with a discount, and a discount on an identical object is only ever a race to the bottom of a market someone else set.

A worksheet for your next order

Before you commit to stock, for each piece:

  1. Confirmed landed cost — goods, freight and duty, not the invoice alone
  2. Outbound shipping quote at the piece's actual weight, with tracking and insurance
  3. Packaging cost
  4. Payment and platform fees as a percentage
  5. Breakage reserve, 2–5%
  6. Dead stock allowance
  7. Target net contribution
  8. Solve for retail — and check it against what comparable pieces actually sell for

If step 8 comes out above the market, do not discount to fix it. Go back to step 1 and change what you buy.

What to ask us

Tell us your target retail price band and how you intend to sell — storefront, marketplace, or both — and we will tell you which sizes and materials fit that band once freight is counted, rather than what looks best in a photograph.

We are a manufacturer, not a marketplace, so we have no interest in pushing you toward the heaviest piece. A first order that prices correctly and sells through is worth more to us than one that sits on your shelf. See how to build your first order for how to structure it, and how to read a quote for what our quotation includes.

Send us your target retail band and we will price the freight before we price the product.