Most importers spend their preparation on duty, freight and paperwork, and almost none spend it on the one thing that is physically attached to the goods and inspected on sight: the country-of-origin mark.
It is a small requirement with an outsized consequence, and it catches people out because it is not a labelling convention. It is a condition of entry.
This is the companion to what you may claim about stone, which covers the words you use to sell. This article covers the mark you must put on the object. They are different obligations, and satisfying one does nothing for the other.
The obligation belongs to the importer
The rule is short. Under section 304 of the Tariff Act of 1930, as amended (19 U.S.C. 1304), and its implementing regulation at 19 CFR § 134.11, every article of foreign origin imported into the United States — or its container — must be marked
> "in a conspicuous place as legibly, indelibly, and permanently as the nature of the article (or container) will permit, in such manner as to indicate to an ultimate purchaser in the United States the English name of the country of origin of the article, at the time of importation."
Four things are being demanded at once, and each one is a separate way to fail:
- Conspicuous — findable without dismantling anything.
- Legible, indelible and permanent — to the degree the object allows.
- In the English name of the country — not a code, not an abbreviation, not a symbol.
- At the time of importation — the mark must already be there when the goods arrive.
The factory applies the mark before shipment, because that is the only practical moment. But the importer of record is who Customs holds responsible. If your supplier's cartons arrive unmarked, "the factory didn't do it" is not a defence available to you — it is a description of how you came to be liable. See how to verify a Chinese stone carving supplier for how to establish, before the first order, whether a factory actually understands this.
Who counts as the "ultimate purchaser"
This is where most small importers get it wrong, and the error is usually one of degree rather than kind.
The regulation defines the ultimate purchaser as "generally the last person in the United States who will receive the article in the form in which it was imported."
Read that against a normal wholesale purchase. A shop buys twenty carvings, they arrive exactly as the factory finished them, and the shop puts them on a shelf. Nobody alters them. So the last person in the United States to receive them in their imported form is not the shop. It is the shop's customer.
That single step changes the specification. The mark is not required to survive only as far as your loading bay. It has to survive normal distribution and store handling and reach the person who buys the piece, and it has to be readable by them. The regulation says so directly at 19 CFR § 134.41(b):
> "The degree of permanence should be at least sufficient to insure that in any reasonably foreseeable circumstance, the marking shall remain on the article (or its container) until it reaches the ultimate purchaser unless it is deliberately removed. The marking must survive normal distribution and store handling. The ultimate purchaser in the United States must be able to find the marking easily and read it without strain."
Two practical consequences follow. A mark on the outer shipping carton is useless if that carton is discarded before the retail sale. And a mark the shop removes on arrival — a paper band, a peel-off sticker, a swing tag taken off for display — was never a mark for these purposes, because the ultimate purchaser never saw it.
Why stone carvings are an awkward case
The standard is not absolute. It says as permanently as the nature of the article will permit, and the regulation acknowledges that some objects cannot reasonably carry a permanent mark. That is not a loophole; it is a recognition that a rule which ignores the material produces absurd results.
For a polished stone carving the tension is real. The method the regulation prefers is marking worked into the article at the time of manufacture — die-sunk or etched into metal, glazed into ceramics, moulded into glass. Applied to a finished, hand-polished quartz or obsidian skull, the equivalent is engraving "Made in China" into a visible surface. On a decorative object sold largely on the quality of its finish, that is a genuine injury to the article, which is one of the statutory exceptions.
19 CFR § 134.32 sets out the general exceptions. The ones that realistically apply to carved stone are:
| Exception | Text | How it applies to a carving |
|---|---|---|
| 134.32(a) | Articles incapable of being marked | Rarely available for stone — a flat base can almost always carry something |
| 134.32(b) | Articles that cannot be marked prior to shipment without injury | The strongest argument where engraving would damage a finished surface |
| 134.32(c) | Marking possible only at economically prohibitive expense | Weak on higher-value pieces, where the cost is small relative to value |
| 134.32(d) | Articles for which marking the container will reasonably indicate the origin | The pragmatic route, provided the container reaches the ultimate purchaser |
| 134.32(i) | Articles produced more than 20 years prior to importation | Not applicable to new production |
The exception most people actually rely on is (d), and the phrase that matters is reasonably indicate. A printed carton that a retailer throws away does not indicate anything to a retail buyer. A permanently affixed base label, an engraved base, or a tag attached in a way that cannot fall off in handling does.
There is also an anti-avoidance clause worth knowing about. The exception for marking that is only possible after importation at prohibitive expense does not apply "unless the importer, producer, seller, or shipper failed to mark the articles before importation to avoid meeting the requirements of the law" (§ 134.32(o)). Deciding not to mark because marking is inconvenient is not the same as being unable to mark.
What a missing mark costs
The consequence is arithmetic, not a warning letter. Under 19 CFR § 134.2, articles not marked as required
> "shall be subject to additional duties of 10 percent of the final appraised value unless exported or destroyed under Customs supervision prior to liquidation of the entry."
Note what that is 10 percent of. Not of the duty owed — of the final appraised value of the goods. On a shipment of twenty carvings appraised at $400 each, the exposure is around $800, on top of whatever else the entry costs. On a single trial order of ten pieces, it can exceed the margin on the entire order.
Customs also has a mechanism to withhold release until goods are marked, and to order redelivery. Both are worse outcomes than marking correctly at the factory, because they cost time as well as money.
> Ordinary import duty rates for carved stone are a separate question from marking, and one this article deliberately does not cover — the rate depends on classification, and getting classification wrong is its own problem. Marking is the part you can control before the goods ever leave the factory.
What actually satisfies the requirement
Practical guidance, in the order that matters:
1. English name of the country. "China". Not "CN", not "PRC", not a flag, not a symbol. The regulation asks for the English name.
2. On the article, or on a container that travels with it to the buyer. If the piece cannot carry a mark without injury, the fallback is a container or attachment that reaches the ultimate purchaser. A felt base with a printed label is a common and workable solution for smaller carvings, provided the label is genuinely permanent rather than a sticker that lifts at the corner.
3. Permanent enough to survive handling. The test in § 134.41(b) is "normal distribution and store handling". A pressure-sensitive label on a rough or dusty stone surface usually fails that test within weeks. A label recessed into a base cavity, an engraved base, or a riveted tag does not.
4. Readable without strain. Small print on the underside of a piece is acceptable if it can be found and read. Illegible micro-printing is not a mark, it is the appearance of one.
5. Present at importation. Applied at the factory, before the carton is sealed. This is a production instruction, not a customs fix.
| Where people put it | Does it work? |
|---|---|
| Engraved into the base | Yes — the strongest option |
| Permanent label recessed in the base | Usually, if genuinely permanent |
| Tag wired through the piece and left on at retail | Yes, if it cannot be removed without deliberate action |
| Peel-off sticker on the outer carton | No, if the carton is discarded before retail |
| Ink stamp on the polished face | Poor — usually not durable, and it damages the finish |
| Invoice, packing list, or product page | No — none of these is a mark on the article |
| Poly bag twist-tie label | No, if the bag is removed at unpacking |
Australia is a different mechanism
It is worth separating the two markets, because importers often assume the Australian rule mirrors the American one. It does not.
Australia's mandatory country-of-origin labelling standard is a food standard. For non-food goods such as stone carvings there is no prescribed origin label of the kind the United States requires. What binds you instead is the general prohibition on misleading conduct in the Australian Consumer Law — and, as the ACCC puts it, claims must be true, accurate and based on reasonable grounds, with the regulator able to require a business to substantiate what it has advertised.
The practical difference is this: in the United States, an unmarked import is a customs problem at the border. In Australia, a wrong origin claim is a consumer-law problem that surfaces later, usually after a complaint. Origin claims for goods made here also attract statutory "safe harbours" with specific criteria — so "Made in Australia" and "Product of Australia" are defined terms, not marketing adjectives, and neither is available for a carving made in Donghai.
If you sell into both markets, the American requirement is the stricter one and satisfying it costs you nothing in Australia. See shipping crystal skulls to Australia for the transport side.
Put it in the purchase order
The mark is decided at ordering, not at arrival. Four lines in a purchase order prevent the entire problem:
- The exact wording. "Made in China" — spelled out, in English, as it must appear.
- The exact location and method. For example: "permanent label recessed into the base cavity of each piece; label to be 25 mm × 10 mm minimum, printed, not handwritten."
- A photograph before balance payment. One clear image of the mark on a production piece, sent with the pre-shipment inspection photos. This is the cheapest possible insurance and it costs one email.
- Who bears the cost of correction. If the mark is missing on arrival, the remedy should already be agreed rather than negotiated under time pressure.
Then check it as part of the arrival inspection — the same walkthrough described in inspecting a stone carving order, with one extra line: is the mark present, legible, in English, and on the piece or on something that will reach your customer?
For anything unusual — a mixed-material piece, a carving with a felt base, an object where any marking would be visible — the reliable way to get certainty is a binding ruling from Customs before you import, rather than an assumption afterwards. Customs publishes rulings on specific articles for exactly this purpose.
The short version
- The mark is a condition of entry, not a labelling preference. The importer of record carries the liability.
- The mark must reach the ultimate purchaser — for a shop reselling as imported, that is the shop's customer, not the shop.
- Permanence is judged against the nature of the object, but "as permanent as the article permits" is not a licence to skip it.
- The cost of getting it wrong is 10 percent of the appraised value of the goods, not 10 percent of the duty.
- Australia has no equivalent mandatory label for non-food goods, but a false origin claim is a consumer-law exposure.
- Decide the wording, position and method in the purchase order, and get a photograph before you pay the balance.
If you are working out what a shipment needs before it leaves Donghai, send us the details — we would rather answer the marking question at quotation stage than have it answered at the border.